Bikram yoga: friend or foe?

bikramJade Jagger, Raquel Welsh, John McEnroe, Robert Downey Junior and Julia Roberts are all fans...

The physical benefits include muscle strength, flexibility and impressive weight loss.

Now claiming to be the fastest growing yoga school in the world, its figurehead has become yoga's most controversial character. The yoga type in question is, of course, Bikram.

 

With 720 studios worldwide and rising, there's no doubting Bikram's impact on the yoga world. A series of 26 postures performed in a room heated to around 108 degrees, Bikram is arguably the most gruelling, and controversial, form of yoga practised today.

Those new to Bikram often complain of nausea and heightened emotion – a sign, Bikram fans say, of a powerful cleansing process brought on by the fierce heat, which is designed to move oxygenated blood to every part of the body and internal organs.

The benefits of suffering

“Which is better: 90 minutes of suffering or 90 years of suffering?”, said Bikram Choudhury, hammering home the point that while Bikram is challenging on all levels, its benefits are designed to last a lifetime.

It's little surprise that around 40% of Bikram's practitioners are men – far higher than the 20% to 30% generally seen in the average yoga class.

The physical benefits are indeed impressive, and include muscle strength and tone, flexibility, weight loss, treatment of diabetes, asthma, high and low blood pressure, and most famously, the treatment of knee and back problems.

The heated room allows muscles, joints, ligaments and tendons to stretch more easily and in a safer atmosphere, while profuse sweating brought on by the heat sends the body into a state of detox.

Courting controversy

Founder Bikram Chouldhury himself is possibly yoga's most controversial figure. An Indian yoga champion and athlete, Choudhury damaged his knees in a weight lifting accident and was told he would never walk again.

But he soon proved the doubters wrong: he and his guru Bishnu Ghosh designed the 26 posture series while curing Bikram's knee, and it wasn't long before Bikram was teaching his new method in Japan, Hawaii and Lost Angeles.

In more recent years, Bikram has attracted more than his fair share of negative press: his move to copyright the sequence of 26 postures attracted a huge amount of controversy.

Those taking issue with Bikram objected to his move to have exclusive control of a series of postures derived from ancient, traditional practises.

Some also objected to the forthright manner in which Bikram conducts his business – notably, plans to create a formal franchise of his studios.

Yoga as competition?

Others object to the strident, competitive approach that Bikram yoga can be said to foster – illustrated by Bikram's recent moves to register this form of yoga as an Olympic sport.

As a yoga-abode member said on the forum recently: “the whole thing has too strong a whiff of machismo to me – more like working out at the gym. The exercises are performed in a a rather irritating military-style drills, and there is no emphasis on the more meditative side.”

Love it or hate it, Bikram has got the world talking yoga, and that, on balance, has to be a pretty good thing.

Have your say at www.yoga-abode.com/node/138

 

www.bikramyogauk.net

www.bikramyoga.com

www.bikramyoga.co.uk

www.bikramyogachiswick.co.uk

www.hotbikramyoga.co.uk

 

 

 

 

LynneAs a relative newcomer

Lynne

As a relative newcomer to yoga, I was seduced by a £10 for 10 days unlimited bikram yoga course and launched myself into it almost on a whim.

 

Had I known what I was in for, I may well have found the idea way too intimidating, and the prospect of a truly tough work out beyond me (being as I am a sporadic jogger and little else); but propelled by the idea of doing my body and mind untold benefit, and cushioned by naivety, I found myself confidently handing over my money and grabbing a mat.

 

My first huge shock was the temperature of the room (see - I knew nothing, nothing!!), and my second shock was the number of people already lying serenely on their mats waiting for class to begin....does no one have a proper job??

 

Clearly used to having a handful of beginners in each class, we were told not to overstretch ourselves, and that the main aim of a first session was to focus on controlled breathing and staying in the room.

 

We started with some pretty full on breathing exercises and moved into stretches and balances which, after 20 minutes, started to make me light headed, then queasy and finally outright nauseous. I wanted to leave the room, get some air and have a drink but was persuaded to sit down, rest and join in again when I could. After a few minutes, my breathing calmed down - so much for keeping that in control - and I decided that I wasn't going to be defeated and would do what I could. I went through the remainder of the 90 minute class perhaps not throwing myself into each sequence with such gusto, but treating my body with a little more respect and allowing it to find its own level; both an enlightening and humbling experience.

 

Staggering out, I congratulated myself for still being able to walk, and determined that I might try the experience again once my body had recovered, if only to "get my money's worth". Believing that surely I had done enough exercise for at least the next few days, I enquired as to when it would be beneficial for me to return, and couldn't believe that the answer was the next day if possible. What?? I doubted that I would be able to crawl out of bed the next day, let alone exercise, but again I was wrong.

 

Unbelievably, although I could feel that I had used muscles that had had it pretty easy for some years, they really didn't ache or feel stiff the following day, and further to that, I found that I wasn't using 101 excuses not to exercise before hauling myself out of the flat and off to my second class. Knowing what to expect meant that I paced myself and, to my delight, I got through the class without the nausea of my first experience.

 

I understand that to yoga aficionados, bikram is a somewhat different discipline, but I would argue that to a new comer, if you can handle the heat, it does seem to share many of the core yoga principles: the focus on breathing; the comparison only with yourself (I was so delighted that I didn't feel ill the second time round, that I honestly didn't care that my contortions were crude, ungainly and frequently off balance); and the stillness of the mind - there is really no room for anything else other than full concentration on what you are asking your body to do, so surely that must be some form of meditation?

Having won me over, I have now signed up for a year, and will continue my practice. Far from being a room full of body beautifuls, I find that it is full of individuals, each of whom are, like me, concentrating intently on their own bodies and their own improvement. Some days are better than others; yesterday I managed the sit ups that I have never quite previously mastered, but every session is different. There is a great deal of focus on correct posture –which ever level you are at – and I am reveling in the rise to the challenge, even though I am assured that in many ways, it doesn’t get easier!

 

 


So, Bikram may be the bad boy of the yoga world but he has inspired me to connect with my body in a way that has really surprised and delighted me. To be honest, I haven't noticed many outward benefits yet, but I am plugging away at it and find that I am more apt these days to thank my body for what it can do rather than berate it for what it can't. That has to be a good thing.

 

Asana of the Month

Fish Pose (Matsayasana)

Fish Pose (Matsayasana)

Practice

Fitness first yoga expert Ashok Naik offers a guide to six main cleansing techniques.

Reviews

Joanne Mallon reviews a timely guide to the safe use of herbal medicines.

Wellbeing

Yoga asanas can help dramatically improve digestion says Sue Fuller, founder of yoga2hear.